What Is an ERISA Violation?

This page was written, edited, reviewed & approved by Emil J. Fleysher following our comprehensive editorial guidelines. Emil J. Fleysher, the Founding Partner, has 15+ years of legal experience as a bankruptcy attorney. Our last modified date shows when this page was last reviewed.

Written By: Emil Fleysher | Published Date: May 28, 2025
What Is an ERISA Violation_

ERISA stands for the Employee Retirement Income Security Act. This federal law sets standards for how employers manage retirement plans, health plans, and other benefit plans offered to their employees. It exists to protect the rights of workers and ensure that plan participants receive the promised benefits from their employer-sponsored benefits plans. When employers violate ERISA, it can result in serious harm to workers who depend on those benefits for their health, income, and future.

Fleysher Law Bankruptcy & Debt Attorneys helps employees understand their rights when something goes wrong with their employee benefit plan. Whether your insurance company denied your claim unfairly or your employer failed to manage your plan documents properly. We can explain your legal options and hold the right parties accountable.

If you believe your benefits were mishandled or withheld, you may be facing one of several possible ERISA violations under the law.

What Is ERISA and What Does It Stand For?

ERISA stands for the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, a federal law passed in 1974 to regulate the way employers offer and manage retirement plans, health plans, and other welfare plans. It sets legal standards for how these plans must be created, maintained, and disclosed to employees, and it also outlines the fiduciary duties that employers and plan administrators must follow when managing plan assets on behalf of their workers.

The law was designed to make sure that workers receive all the benefits they were promised and are given accurate, timely information about their plans. It also ensures that plan participants have access to the plan documents, know their rights, and can take legal action if those rights are violated.

ERISA is enforced by several government agencies, including the Employee Benefits Security Administration, the Internal Revenue Service, and the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation.

Purpose of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act

The main purpose of ERISA is to protect workers who rely on employer-sponsored benefits by holding employers and plan administrators legally responsible for how they manage and deliver those benefits.

It ensures that employees receive their retirement savings, health benefits, and other group plan benefits as promised under the law. ERISA also gives employees the right to sue in federal court when these protections are violated.

Types of Plans Covered

  • Retirement Plans: These include 401(k), pension plans, and profit-sharing plans, which are intended to provide income after retirement.
  • Health Benefit Plans: These cover health insurance coverage, treatment limits, and other forms of health plan coverage.
  • Disability and Welfare Plans: Plans that offer life insurance, short-term disability, long-term disability, and other welfare plans.
  • Group Benefit Plans: Employer-sponsored coverage that includes multiple benefit types, such as group health plans and retirement options.

What Constitutes an ERISA Violation?

What Constitutes an ERISA Violation_

ERISA violations happen when employers or plan administrators fail to follow the rules set by law. Below are the most common types of violations.

Mismanagement of Plan Assets

Employers and plan administrators must act in the best interest of the plan participants. Using plan money for personal expenses or poor investments is a serious breach of fiduciary responsibilities and one of the most common ERISA violations.

Denial of Legitimate Benefits

Unfairly denying benefits is a frequent issue. When insurance companies refuse valid health or disability claims, it may violate both ERISA and disability laws if the decision ignores the plan documents or grievance and appeals process.

Breach of Fiduciary Duty

Anyone responsible for managing benefits has fiduciary duties. If they fail to protect the plan beneficiaries or make decisions that benefit themselves instead of the employees, they may be breaching fiduciary duties under the law.

Failure to Provide Required Plan Information

ERISA requires plan administrators to give plan participants full access to plan documents, benefit summaries, and required notices. Refusing to provide participants with this information can trigger legal claims.

Retaliation Against Employees Who Assert Rights

If an employer punishes or fires an employee for filing a claim or reporting a violation, it can be considered illegal retaliation under ERISA. Protecting employee complaints is one of the law’s core goals.

Common Examples of ERISA Violations

Understanding real-world examples helps workers know when their rights might be violated.

Using Plan Funds for Personal Gain

When employers or trustees use plan assets for vacations, personal bills, or unrelated business expenses, they commit serious violations. This is illegal under ERISA and can lead to criminal and civil penalties.

Unreasonable Denial of Health or Disability Claims

Rejecting valid claims without reviewing medical evidence or following proper procedure is one of the most common ERISA violations. Insurance companies are acting in bad faith or ignoring their obligations as plan administrators.

Failing to Remit Employee Contributions

Employers are required to send employee deductions to the plan on time. Holding onto contributions or using them for other purposes is illegal. This may apply to retirement savings, health benefits, or both.

Providing False or Misleading Plan Information

When an employer or plan administrator gives incorrect details about plan features, eligibility, or coverage, it can prevent employees from making informed choices. This misrepresentation can lead to fewer benefits or even a loss of certain benefits.

Legal Remedies for ERISA Violations

Legal Remedies for ERISA Violations

Victims of ERISA violations have several legal options available depending on the type of harm suffered.

Reinstatement of Denied Benefits: If your benefits were unfairly denied, the court may require the employer or insurance company to reinstate them. This includes health plan coverage, disability payments, or access to your employee benefit plan.

Recovery of Financial Losses: You may be able to recover lost earnings, contributions, or plan growth that you would have received without the violation. Courts can also award civil penalties in some cases involving serious misconduct.

Injunctive Relief and Plan Corrections: Courts can order employers to fix broken procedures or correct errors in their ERISA plan. This may include changes to how plan documents are handled or new steps for ERISA compliance.

Attorney’s Fees and Costs: ERISA allows successful employees to recover legal fees and costs. Hiring an experienced ERISA attorney means you won’t bear the full cost of enforcing your rights if you win in federal court.

When to Contact an ERISA Attorney

If your benefits were mismanaged or unfairly denied, don’t wait. Here are the times when legal help is most important:

If Your Benefits Were Denied

If your health benefits, disability, or retirement plans were denied without clear reason, you may be able to file an administrative appeal. If that fails, your ERISA lawyer can help you take the case to federal court.

If You Suspect Plan Mismanagement

If you believe your employer is using plan funds improperly, failing to meet certain obligations, or delaying payments, it’s time to speak with an attorney. This could include violations of fiduciary duties or criminal action.

If You’ve Been Retaliated Against for Filing a Complaint

If you lost your job, missed out on promotions, or were punished for asserting your ERISA rights, your employer may have broken the law. Protecting workers from retaliation is a key part of ERISA compliance.

FAQs

No. Governmental entities, such as public schools or city governments, are generally not covered by ERISA. These employers follow different benefit rules but may still need to comply with other laws that protect workers' rights.

ERISA sets minimum standards for how plan administrators must operate employee benefit plans. These include rules on how they provide benefits, handle funds, disclose plan information, and avoid conflicts of interest. Employers must also act in the best interests of employees.

Yes. If your rights are violated, you can file a civil action in federal court. This legal step may help recover denied benefits, force plan corrections, or hold employers accountable for wrongdoing.

Yes. Employers must inform plan participants of any material modifications to their benefit plans, such as coverage limits, costs, or eligibility rules. Failure to notify workers properly may be an ERISA violation.

Generally speaking, yes. ERISA may protect health benefits that cover substance abuse treatment. However, coverage and enforcement depend on the specific plan documents and are evaluated on a case-by-case basis.

Contact Our Florida ERISA Violation Attorney for a Free Case Consultation

Contact Our Florida ERISA Violation Attorney for a Free Case Consultation

If you believe your benefits were mismanaged, denied, or used improperly, you may have the right to take legal action. Fleysher Law Bankruptcy & Debt Attorneys stands up for employees across Florida who are facing serious ERISA violations and need real help to recover what they’ve earned.

We know how insurance companies, employers, and plan administrators try to avoid responsibility, and we fight to make sure you get the benefits you deserve. Whether it’s through a successful administrative appeal or a strong case in federal court, we’ll be with you every step of the way.

Your rights are protected under ERISA; let us help you defend them. Contact our team today for a free consultation with an experienced Florida ERISA lawyer. We’re here to help you protect your future and recover the benefits you’ve worked for.

Emil Fleysher
Bankruptcy & Debt Lawyer

Emil specializes in consumer bankruptcy, debt settlement, and mortgage modification, offering a holistic approach to solving mortgage and debt problems. Emil listens to clients, understands their circumstances and goals, and helps them make the right choices by presenting all options and contingencies. 

He is dedicated to helping South Floridians regain their financial freedom from overwhelming debt caused by high interest credit cards, bad mortgage loans, and uninsured medical expenses.

View Profile
Request A
Free Consultation

"*" indicates required fields

Name*
Please share a brief description of your financial or debt problems. We'll promptly review your submission and get back to you with more information or to schedule a free consultation with our attorney.
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form
This field is hidden when viewing the form

*Required Fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
All
Cape Coral
Deerfield Beach
Jacksonville
Lake Worth
Orlando
Palm Beach Gardens
Port St. Lucie
Stuart
Tampa
chevron-down linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram